The Concept of Civilization in Modern Studies of the Neolithic in China and Japan
The Concept of Civilization in Modern Studies of the Neolithic in China and Japan
doi:10.17746/1563-0110.2023.51.2.038-048
M.A. Kudinova1, D.A. Ivanova2, and A.V. Tabarev1 1Institute of Archaeology and Ethnography, Siberian Branch, Russian Academy of Sciences, Pr. Akademika Lavrentieva 17, Novosibirsk, 630090, Russia 2Far Eastern Federal University, Ayaks sttl. 10, Russky Island, Vladivostok, 690922, Russia
This paper presents a brief overview of studies exploring the origin of civilizations in modern archaeology of China and Japan and mostly concerning the Neolithic period. The analysis of publications shows that in Chinese and Japanese archaeology, original scholarly traditions have been developed, with their own methodological foundations and terminology. We outline the key ideas relating to the origin of civilization, elaborated by researches in China (Su Bingqi, Yan Wenming, Li Boqian, Xu Hong, Gao Jiangtao) and Japan (Harunari Hideji, Watanabe Hiroshi, Sasaki Fujio, Yasuda Yoshinori). We show that most Chinese scholars consider the formation of state a sine qua non of transition to the civilization stage. However, the problem of identifying criteria of civilization and state formation using archaeological data has not been resolved to date. Examples of archaeological markers of civilization proposed by Chinese specialists are listed. In the works by Japanese researchers, no connection between the emergence of the state and civilization has been revealed. Most Chinese archaeologists date the emergence of civilization and of the first state formations to the Late Neolithic (Dawenkou, Hongshan, Liangzhu, Longshan, etc.), ca 3500-2000 BC. There are alternative hypotheses—the Early Bronze Age (Erlitou culture) and the Late Bronze Age (the Spring and Autumn period). In Japanese archaeology, there are two main positions regarding the time when civilization had formed—the Jomon period (Neolithic) and the subsequent Yayoi period (Bronze Age). Scholarly and external (includingpolitical) factors that have influenced modern concepts of the origin of civilization require special historiographic research.
Keywords: China, Japan, civilization, Neolithic, archaeological criteria of civilization
